Kindle for Mac review: Just the basics (updated)

(Updated 10/19/10) Well, the free Kindle application for Macintosh computers has finally arrived. The press release is here, which repeats the promise that there will be an app for the iPad as well. It’s pretty much what you would expect, with all the flaws and strengths of the prior apps, starting with the iPhone/iPod Touch app released about a year ago. Like the earlier extensions of the Kindle platform, many some features are curtailed or missing in the Mac app but it’s still a great if basic ebook reader.

First off, it’s finally possible to read your Kindle ebooks on a Mac without any need for the Kindle device. In fact, it’s now easier than ever to start buying and reading Kindle ebooks without ever buying the Kindle.

Start the program and you get a standard screen of ebooks you’ve previously downloaded to the computer. A quick click away is your entire library of Kindle ebooks stored on Amazon’s servers in the “cloud” (see picture below). It’s handy and convenient but still no access to files you’ve loaded manually on your Kindle device, ebooks from other vendors or any of your blog, newspaper or magazine subscriptions. I did look to see if there was some way to send subscriptions directly to the program instead of to your Kindle device but struck out.

Pages of text look great and you can switch font sizes and change the margin width with a click (see picture below). You flip to the next page by clicking with your mouse, hitting the right arrow key, enter key or space key on the keyboard or using a scroll wheel on a magic mouse. Page turns are instantaneous. And the app syncs all books to the last page you’ve read on any of your Kindle apps or devices.


But, like all the other application versions, it’s still not the holistic Kindle experience I’d like to see. Click on the big, friendly button that says “Shop in Kindle Store” and what happens? Your web browser opens separately and goes to the Kindle store web page. Likewise, if you click on the drop-down menu item “Manage your Kindle…” you get whisked off to the web page via your default browser.

There is a convenient notes and bookmarks bar that jumps off the right side of the page if you click on the “Notes & Marks” button. And you can add new bookmark spots with the Mac application.

UPDATE: And with the updated version released in October, 2010, you can finally highlight text for a clipping and add new notes. You can also now search within the book you’re reading though not through your entire library like you can on the Kindle hardware.

You’re still stuck with the usual Kindle organization issue — there are no folders and no way to see your library of ebooks except sorted by how recently viewed, author or by title. I do love the colorful icons depicting the book jackets.

Amazon says, as of October, they are “thinking about” adding the dictionary look-up and “a new way to manage, organize, and search your content,” whatever that means.

So progress for us Mac heads but no revelations in the new Kindle app for Macs.


by

Comments

16 responses to “Kindle for Mac review: Just the basics (updated)”

  1. eBook Reader Review Guy Avatar

    Wonder how the readability on the iPad compares to the EInk screens?

  2. Ed C Avatar
    Ed C

    Bad news for PPC owners, Kindle For Mac is for Intel only.

  3. d2photo Avatar
    d2photo

    We'll all find out in just a bit over 2 weeks

  4. PCS Avatar
    PCS

    Seriously? Get rid of that PPC!

  5. pBody Avatar
    pBody

    my PPC will eat your Intel for breakfast.

  6. Colin Brennan Avatar

    After adapting to read ebooks on a Kindle, I will be happy to adapt back to reading them on the Mac. Don't know how anybody could adapt to reading on an iphone or similar device. You would end up with glasses as thick as Mr. Magoo

  7. Dan_b Avatar
    Dan_b

    October 31, 2010: I’m an experienced software user and an engineer. Here’s my review of Kindle for Mac: you’ll be sorry if you try to use it. It’s garbage. I wasted my money on an e-book. It takes some really bad amateur programming to actually lock up Unix, but they can do that consistently. This isn’t a product. It isn’t a Beta or even an Alpha. This should never have been offered for download in it’s present condition. Amazon is completely clueless about software QA.

    This explains why there are no user reviews of this product on Amazon.

  8. ampressman Avatar

    Sorry the program doesn’t work for you. Have you upgraded to the latest version? Works great for me and most of the other reviewers I have seen.

  9. Dan_b Avatar
    Dan_b

    Downloaded from Amazon yesterday. How much newer could it be today? MacOS: latest, 10.6.4. They must be joking! It’s not QA’d. It can’t be.

  10. Dan_b Avatar
    Dan_b

    Exception Type: EXC_CRASH (SIGABRT)
    Exception Codes: 0x0000000000000000, 0x0000000000000000
    Crashed Thread: 0 Dispatch queue: com.apple.main-thread

    I’m NOT expert at this, but a little Googling indicates this may be a major crash. The app cannot initialize. Very disappointing. I was so looking forward to reading the book I just bought for only $9.95 and downloaded.

  11. Phonecards Avatar

    Sorry. I am enjoying Kindle on both my 3G 32GB iPod touch and now on my 17″ MacBook Pro. I find both versions convenient, accessible, and quite useable. Am I just not as sophisticated as those here who write that these apps stink? I don’t think so. I enjoy reading books with Kindle on my devices. If it wasn’t enjoyable, I’d state that.

  12. The SEO Expert Avatar

    Great review, I was thinking of this for my iPhone :-)

  13. SEO USA Avatar

    It’s really great review and i am so glad to see this information here..

  14. Buy domain name Avatar

    What a wonderful article? You have described very well. How you got this idea? Great work.

  15. Sea_nest Avatar
    Sea_nest

    I can’t find out why my Kindle for Mac does not show page numbers, or if page numbers are just not used on tablets.  Without page numbers, you can’t cite anything.

  16. Brittany Armstrong Avatar
    Brittany Armstrong

    did you ever find out how to see page numbers for this Sea_nest? I am having the same trouble?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *